Down on NFL, Down on Myself

As down as I am on the NFL about now, I’m even more disappointed in myself.

See, if there’s anybody who knows that sports should be about enjoyment and fun and not frustration and angst, it should be one who spent a professional life writing about sports for a daily newspaper.

The best lesson for any sportswriter to learn is to not become emotionally invested in who wins or loses a game. You can be a fan or you can be a sportswriter, but you can’t be both if you want to do your job the way it should be done.

I’ve seen too many try, but in my eyes at least, they all failed.

But here I sit at age 66 all wound up about the way the NFC Championship between the Saints and the Rams came down. The taste is so sour in my mouth I’m not sure I can even tune in to the Super Bowl – not that anybody cares, or should care.

The big joke on me is that I’m not even all that into pro football. With each passing year as a sportswriter, I drifted further and further from those sports that I wasn’t directly responsible for covering, to the point that I rarely, these days, watch NFL until the playoffs begin.

If it’s every other year and the Panthers are on the prowl, then I might tune in. But invariably by the third time Cam Newton is called for delay of game my mind has wandered off to my music, some computer game or the two or three books I’m reading at any point in time.

But other than the Panthers, my favorite team is the Saints. I love the city, I love how the city has rallied around its team and I really love how Drew Brees and Sean Payton, et. al., rallied around the city after Katrina stomped through.

Plus they do gold and black better than any sports franchise I can think of.

So to see the Saints get so close to the Super Bowl, and to see how they were denied was such a bitter pill that now, even two days later, I’m having trouble choking it down.

Speaking of choking. . .

No, we’ll get to that later.

By now we’ve all seen the play and replays and heard all the commentary. The verdict is unanimous. The Saints got screwed. Even the perpetrator, Nickell Robey-Coleman, the cornerback who steamrolled receiver TommyLee Lewis, acknowledged that the Saints got screwed.

“Yes, I got there too early,’’ Robey-Coleman said. “I was beat, and I was trying to save the touchdown.’’

Of course that’s a bit like Bill Buckner admitting he botched the grounder in the 1986 World Series. Robey-Coleman is only telling everyone what everyone saw.

Everyone, apparently, except those who matter most – the officials responsible for making the call.

What’s mind-boggling is that replay should not have even been needed. We all saw what we saw. And when we did see the replay, the no-call was even more egregious — in that a strong case could be made that Robey-Coleman should have been called for helmet-to-helmet contact.

A distraught Peyton revealed his conversation with Al Riveron, the NFL’s vice president of officiating, and how Riveron admitted both penalties should have been called. But I have to say it bothers me to no end that the NFL has yet to officially address the issue.

And had they been called, the Saints have the ball inside the 10-yard line with 1:49 remaining. With only two timeouts remaining, the Rams would have had no way to prevent the Saints from running the clock almost out before attempting a short field goal to win the game.

Here’s where I admit that I was impressed with the Rams, and how they capitalized on their great fortune to take control in overtime. They’re a great team, and if they can beat the Patriots, they’ll be a great champion.

And I also freely acknowledge that there were other blown calls in the game. But seldom in my career have I seen a call or no-call so directly affect the outcome of a game.

My heart bleeds for the Saints and their awesome fans, the fans that simply wouldn’t let their team lose in the NFL semi-final against Philadelphia and who made life so miserable on the Rams. But to be charitable, I also feel sorry for the seven officials who called the game – and particularly the one (ostensibly either the back judge or the side judge) who was most responsible for making the call.

In their gut they have to know they they or he – and not Jared Goff or Drew Brees or Sean McVay or Sean Payton – were most responsible for extending the Rams’ season and, as Saints’ owner Gayle Benson put it, unfairly depriving one team from playing in the Super Bowl.

And that has to be a horrible feeling.

To date I’ve not seen the official or officials most responsible outed, and I’m glad for that. No need for lynch mobs, whether it be on social media or in public.

That said I really don’t see how the official or officials most responsible should ever call another NFL game. I know that’s harsh, in that we’re talking about people’s livelihood.

But to pursue a livelihood, one has to prove they’re up to the responsibility. And faced with that responsibility, at least one official and possibly two choked for all the world to see.

They can’t be counted on not choking again.

I wish I could say I felt a little better after getting all this off my chest, but in my mind, until the NFL improves its officiating it will remain a joke – a bad joke at that.

What I’d like to write is that I’ve evolved past the point where an outcome of an athletic event could get me so riled up.

But one no call in New Orleans clearly proved I’ve not.

4 thoughts on “Down on NFL, Down on Myself

  1. Great commentary, Dan. I often think of the comment attributed to Bones McKinney, that the problem with referees is that they don’t care who wins the game. I believe he may have been trying to make a different point, but officiating can have a direct impact on outcome of a game and it is frustrating that with a product as polished as the NFL, issues such as this keep happening. I admit I don’t know of a perfect solution. Certainly replays and challenges on penalties/no-calls would extend games considerably. But would it be so bad if there were an “eye in the sky” ref, one watching the came form the booth who could signal penalties (at least obvious ones) in real time? Certainly everyone who saw the play, other than the ref(s) on the field, understood there was at least one obvious penalty on that play. Beyond that, given the rightful concern about concussions and other injuries caused by hits to the head, it seems only sensible to empower a referee or referees observing from a remove with the aid of multiple video angles to call the dangerous helmet to helmet penalties that might be missed on the field.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The NFL’s use of replays to adjust the time clock by 2 seconds or to confirm far more questionably close calls is a mockery when the worst call I have seen is made in front of 78000 people and two teams, everyone of which knew the call was wrong. If you are not going to use replay and technology to correct grievous mistakes then don’t use it at all.


    1. Sean Payton is not a good guy Dan at least with regard to the NFL. He missed a season because of it and his Saints went to the Super Bowl after repeatedly hitting Brett Fabre late and trying to injure him (Bounty-gate). They had help from negligent refs in that game and didn’t deserve to advance.

      Additionally, this year, with his team ahead of the Eagle’s 41-7 late in the 4th quarter, Payton called for a bomb on a 4th down play which resulted in a TD and a 48-7 win. It was a classless move, but he’s pretty much known for that.

      So, no tears from me for the Saints and you can drift from the NFL if you’d like, but the rest of the country won’t be joining you. Sunday provided the most compelling 7 1/2 hours that you’ll see anywhere. It was awesome and a human error by a ref won’t change that.


      1. Hey Bob. Thanks for the input. Much appreciated. My opinion just comes from my own world, like yours comes from yours. Guess we can both be right in own world. And thanks for reading.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s